Due process rights definition11/9/2023 Note that the basis of the discrimination, a criminal defendant’s status as a convicted felon, is rational, not arbitrary like race. Criminal statutes that punish felons more severely when they have a history of criminal behavior, for example, three-strikes statutes, are supported by the legitimate government interests of specific and general deterrence and incapacitation. Virginia, 2010).Ĭriminal statutes that have a rational basis for discrimination and are supported by a legitimate government interest can discriminate, and frequently do. Modern courts do not uphold criminal statutes that classify based on race because there is no government interest in treating citizens of a different race more or less harshly (Loving v. Statutes containing classifications that are not arbitrary must have a rational basis and be supported by a legitimate government interest.Ĭriminal statutes that classify individuals based on their race must be given strict scrutiny because race is an arbitrary classification that cannot be justified. ![]() The most arbitrary classifications demand strict scrutiny, which means the criminal statute must be supported by a compelling government interest. Arbitrary means random and often includes characteristics an individual is born with, such as race or national origin. ![]() In general, court scrutiny is heightened according to a sliding scale when the subject of discrimination is an arbitrary classification. The prohibition on governmental discrimination is not absolute it depends on the class of persons targeted for special treatment. The Fifth Amendment due process clause prohibits the federal government from discrimination if the discrimination is so unjustifiable that it violates due process of law (Bolling v. The equal protection clause prevents the state government from enacting criminal laws that discriminate in an unreasonable and unjustified manner. State constitutions generally have a similar provision (California Constitution, 2010). ![]() The Fourteenth Amendment states in relevant part, “nor shall any State…deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.” The equal protection clause applies to the state government. Thus although the original focus of the Bill of Rights may have been limiting the federal government, modern interpretations of the Constitution ensure that its protections also extend to all levels of state and local government. This doctrine is called selective incorporation, and it includes virtually all the constitutional protections in the Bill of Rights. However, US Supreme Court precedent has held that any constitutional amendment that is implicit to due process’s concept of ordered liberty must be incorporated into the Fourteenth Amendment’s protections and applied to the states (Duncan v. The Bill of Rights was originally written to apply to the federal government. In addition, the Fourteenth Amendment, which was added to the Constitution after the Civil War, has a plethora of protections for criminal defendants in the due process and equal protection clauses. The Bill of Rights is the first ten amendments to the Constitution. Ascertain the purpose of the equal protection clause as it applies to criminal laws.Īlthough the legislative branch’s prohibited powers are in Article I of the Constitution, the Bill of Rights contains most of the constitutional protections afforded to criminal defendants. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply.AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |